Saturday, October 26, 2013

NAfME Pre-Conference Day One

By some miracle, my school district (county) saw fit to provide grant money so that I could attend the NAfME conference in Nashville, TN. Woohoo! Or should I say, Yeehaw!

So here I am at the Gaylord Opryland Hotel having just finished Day One of the Pre-Conference focused on Teacher Evaluation and Student Assessment... both hot topics in education, but particularly in music education.

I am battling very slow WiFi, so I am not sure when/if this post will upload.

The day opened with remarks from NAfME President-Elect Glenn Nierman and NAfME Deputy Executive Director & COO Mike Blakelee.

Why Focus on Teacher Evaluation Now?
  • ESEA (NCLB) is up for reauthorization
  • Research has proven that teacher efficacy directly impacts student achievement 
  • Race To The Top has put greater emphasis on evaluation, assessment, and accountability.

Based on the three items above, there are two primary concerns:

  1. Are we teaching to look good and not to do good?
  2. How do we collect data on student growth?

Mike also introduced the "Workbook" which we will tackle in depth during the sessions tomorrow:

Workbook for Bulding and Evaluating Effective Music Education

  • Section 1: Supporting Structures
  • Section 2: Curricular Goals & Measures
  • Section 3: Observations
  • Section 4: Other Outcomes

Next up was Beth Cummings from Polk County, Florida.


Polk County (Florida) Performing Fine Arts Assessments Project
This project is funded by RTTT to create summative and formative assessments of individual achievement, instead of group achievement (such as in ensembles).
The assessments focus on Responding, Performing, and Creating Music.

Although there are MANY benchmarks for each course (200-350), assessment items attached to only the benchmarks that can be best assessed in the classroom and are essential to learning.

Those creating the assessments wanted to reflect what is important to the classroom teachers.


Performing benchmarks are combined into tasks divided into Prepared (time to practice), On Demand (sight-reading), and Creating (improvise); rubrics for each type

All Responding assessments are on computer! 30-40 minutes total (30%)
Performing assessments are no longer than 15 minutes (70%)

CONCERN: When can we test since the students are already facing lots of testing?


NOTE: There is a website, however the slow WiFi will not let me test the links prior to posting. I will update when I have a more reliable connection.


Doug Orzolek presented Research, Issues, and Trends in Teacher Evaluation

Doug's Categories of Teacher Evaluation

  • Linked to student outcomes (SLOs and assessments)
  • Linked to observations
  • Linked to self-assessment and reflection
  • Linked to all three (multifaceted evals)
From MET (Gates Foundation):
External observations are a good ongoing check for internal bias.
Observers should be trained in observation and should always be done by more than one observer.
The more lessons and observers, the higher the reliability of the evaluation.
1/3 each student survey, observation, and reflection combined for the evaluation yields the highest reliability (.76)

Danielson "Framework for Teaching" is reliable, especially since it encourages reflection and self-assessment, however the tool needs to be adapted and changed to be music ed friendly.



David Hawley presented recent changes in SmartMusic in relation to student assessment.
  • Added a new Rubric scoring option; rubric is teacher-created
  • Added a mic check prior to playing
  • Click on errors to see corrections, as many takes as they want
  • Added an open response assignment option utilizing NotePad
  • Added state standards


RTTT Teacher Evaluation 
Dru Davison presented the TN Fine Arts Student Growth Measures.
Since current assessment options (MAP, SLO, teacher-created or district-created assessments) were not applicable, the solution is a flexible but rigorous portfolio, demonstrating student work and utilizing peer review)

System Requirements:

  • 5 evidence collections (sampling) - teacher choice reflective of course load
  • Collection shows evidence of student growth in 3 out of 4: Perform, Create, Respond, Connect
  • Self-scored, then peer review
  • Built in secondary peer review for instance of disagreement
Challenges to creating the system: must be time efficient, must account for limited tech, must account for inequity of resources/class time/curricular support, must have a fair peer review system, and must move towards standards-based instruction

The Gladis Project created a cloud-based evidence collection tool which allows for double-blind peer review and accepts a variety of formats.



After a lunch break, we were presented with the correlations between Music Literacy and Common Core by Amy Charleroy & Johanna Siebert. These were too numerous (which is a good thing!) to list here.

The NAfME Immediate Past-President, Scott Shuler, then teamed up with Richard Wells.
Re-Imagined Standards, Student Assessment, and Teacher Evaluation
Common Music Assessment Project
Why? Transferable, Consistent Quality, Reliable, Credible
"If the teachers can't score [the assessment,] it is not of any use."

Core Arts Standards & Cornerstone Assessments - http://nccas.wikispaces.com
  • Public Review - December 2013
  • Final Version - March 2014
Creating, Performing, & Responding (Connecting is embedded) - CPR+
Cornerstone Assessments are designed to provide models of quality assessments and to generate student work to illustrate standards.

The Connecticut Department of Education created a website with tons of examples for teachers regarding student assessment. Select "Task Search," select "Music" from the drop down menu and keyword search "CTCAA."


Lynn Tuttle then emphasized the wide variations between states on meeting federal requirements of teacher evaluation. If 68% of the teaching workforce (in Arizona) are teachers of "non-tested" subjects; why are we then held accountable to assessments that we do not directly impact?

The final session of the day was a presentation by Chris Woodside who outlined what NAfME has been working on in the policy sphere on the National level. He also discussed the "Groundswell" advocacy tools available on the NAfME website.

Overall, the day was highly informative and the presenters provided valuable information on the background of the evaluation and assessment movement. I look forward to tomorrow and being able to get "hands-on" with the tools NAfME has created for music teachers.

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Back to School, the Band Way

If you hadn't noticed, I took the summer off. Well, I didn't completely take the summer off. I was working at a local community music school as well as preparing for the new school year, however I did not blog for a few months.

I have returned and I am starting out by sharing my lesson plans from the first 2 days of school.

For the first time in 12 years, I am teaching ONLY band classes this year. I know: MIRACLE. I have taught band, general music, guitar, piano, theatre, foreign language exploratory and remedial math. This is refreshing and I'm hoping it will help me to focus and provide a better overall plan for my students.

Here is the break down of my teaching schedule:

On A days (every other day) I see my 7th & 8th grade Concert Bands (on grade-level ability) for 80 minutes each, and my 6th grade Advanced Bands (started playing in elementary school) for 38 minutes each divided into a woodwinds/percussion class and a brass/percussion class.

On B days (the opposite day) I see my 7th & 8th grade Symphonic Bands (advanced ability) for 80 minutes each, and my 6th grade Beginning Bands (never played before) for 38 minutes each divided into a woodwinds/percussion class and a brass/percussion class.

The program is growing, with a total of 160 students this year. Of course, I'm aiming higher ;)

For the first days of school, I decided to keep the activities interactive. There's a lot of "policies" and "procedures" in all of the classes, so I needed to keep their interest.

Day One, Step One: Attendance
I need to take attendance to make sure the students are in the correct classroom and to make sure I am not missing anyone. Instead of responding with "here" or "present," I ask them to respond with a Musical Term. It can be as simple as the name of their instrument, they can look at the words posted around the classroom, or they can state a term they remembered from last year. I was impressed by 6th grade students saying "fortissimo" or "crescendo." Side note: for the next 2 classes, the students insisted on taking attendance in this manner since they enjoyed it so much.

Day One, Step Two: Non-Negotiables
In my school building, we have a set of 4 Non-Negotiables which guide student behavior. These are reviewed and briefly discussed (with examples) to reinforce that the guidelines are school-wide. Student volunteers read the Non-Negotiable aloud and then we discuss the meaning.

Day One, Step Three: Who is Mrs. McEndree?
I created a PicStitch of six scenes from my summer. For students who I had last year, it was an opportunity to "catch up" with them. For the new students, it gave them a glimpse into my life and who I am.

Day One, Step Four: Incredibox
Thanks to the Facebook Band Directors group, I was introduced to the awesomeness of Incredibox. I use this as a tool to encourage the students to introduce themselves and tell something about their summer. To be able to use the ActivSlate and manipulate the "groove" being created, they have to share. They were so excited to share and work with the website! They often request to play with Incredibox when waiting for buses at the end of the day!

Day One, Step Five: Writing Rhythms
This step is not completed by the 6th grade students, since their class was half the length of the 7th & 8th grade classes. The students create rhythms on whiteboards based on guidelines (4-beats, 8-beats), and then random students are selected to create the rhythm on the screen, using the ActivInspire program and the ActivSlate. The entire class tapped/clapped the rhythms, and then we selected rhythms to add additional sound effects. For example, a rhythm might end up as clap-pat-pat-snap-rub-clap-clap.

Thus ended the lesson for Day One. I save the Band Policies and Procedures for the second class, since I know they are inundated with this information in all other classes on the first day.

Day Two, Step One: Attendance
The students respond with a Music Term to verify attendance for the day.

Day Two, Step Two: Policies Scavenger Hunt
Which student really wants to read through the class policies? The student that is being given candy! I make a game out of reading through the policies, in which a correct answer earns a small piece of candy. The process is simple. A question is displayed on the screen (using PowerPoint or ActivInspire). When the students find the answer in the policies, they stand at their chair. I select a student to answer the question,making sure every student has the opportunity to earn candy. All correct answers earn a piece of candy. Many of the questions have multiple parts: How many Musicianship points can you earn each class and how do you earn them? The students then enjoy learning (or reviewing, for returning band students) the class policies and are actively engaged in the lesson.

Day Two, Step Three: Review Non-Negotiables
Another reminder of the school-wide Non-Negotiables

Day Two, Step Four: Band Participation Self-Assessment
This step is not completed by the 6th grade students, since their class was half the length of the 7th & 8th grade classes. Based on a document I found on Teachers-Pay-Teachers, I give the students a Band Participation Self-Assessment. As a point of clarification, the students are able to mark multiple answers for one question. After the students complete the assessment and complete the tally, we share answers in a general sense: I read each question aloud and ask the students the raise their hand (if they feel comfortable) as I read the answer they selected. Once finished reading the questions, I ask them to raise hands based on their final tally. Only at this point do I share with them how the tally relates to their probable success in class. Then we discuss ideas for changing their habits to increase success in class.

The students seemed to really enjoy their first two band classes. Although I went through a lot of candy, it was worth it to have them actively and positively reading the policies. The 7th & 8th grade bands began performing on instruments for the third class, while the 6th grade classes began rhythm and melody reviews prior to performing on instruments (and as a way to buy some time while they rent instruments and purchase method books).

I hope your first few days go as smoothly as mine. I try to rotate "First Day" activities, so that the returning band students do not repeat an activity (although the Scavenger Hunt is a yearly favorite!).

Sunday, June 2, 2013

End-of-the-Year Packets

The annual question: what to do in band class following the spring concert?

Each year I have experimented with different activities to do with the days (or weeks) that follow the band spring concert, from sight-reading music for the next year to making recordings of music for future students to composing music. The students and I enjoyed the set of activities that were completed last year, so I decided to improve upon it this year and create a packet.

Cover page to a packet
Each class received a slightly different packet, each including activities they were required to complete and additional optional activities.

OPINION SURVEY: Each student was required to complete an opinion survey. For 7th grade students it including questions regarding activities and music from this school year, as well as questions about next year. For 8th grade students, I did not include the questions about next year. I asked the students NOT to put their name on this survey; I hope to receive honest opinions through anonymity. This was the back page of the packet; once the survey was complete, the student pulled off the page and handed it to me. I marked on my grade-sheet that the student completed the task.

COMPOSE A MELODY: Each student was required to compose an 8-measure melody for their instrument. I gave them guidelines: it must be in a key (use a scale as a guide), it must use all 7 pitches of the key, the key must be accurately noted, and it can be composed using the rhythm given or with an original rhythm. Percussion students had the option of creating the entire 8-measures for bells, or splitting it 4 for bells (with all guidelines followed) and 4 for snare (rhythm entirely original). The student had the option of performing the composition for me as bonus. I graded based on adherence to the guidelines.

SELECT A PLAYING QUIZ: Each student was required to perform a final playing quiz. Each class was given a choice between 2 exercises at the current playing level, except for the advanced 8th grade class: these students could select any exercise (not including warm-ups or scale) to perform. Percussion were asked to complete half the quiz on bells and half on snare. This is standard in my classroom; this way I can check both skill sets (note-reading on bells and technique on snare) without asking them to perform more measures than the rest of the band. I included the grading rubric for the quiz on the back of the front page to the packet. When the student was ready to play, I used their rubric to grade and give feedback and wrote the grade on my grade sheet. The student kept the rubric and were able to practice and perform again if they wanted to improve.

PAY YOUR BAND DEBT: This only applied to students who owed fees for books or rentals, or needed to check-in a school-owned instrument.

WHAT DO YOU MEME?: This optional activity asked students to look at band-related photos (2 were of our actual students) and create memes that will be postures for our classroom next year.
Meme Bulletin Board
There are 3 complete meme examples at the top and then 9 photos to use for new memes. The two photos directly below the green sign are of band students. I have not read all of their ideas, however the ones shown to me are really funny!! I'm debating using my judgement to select the best/funniest, or allow them to vote in the fall and then have the posters created.

TOP 3 TIPS FOR BAND SUCCESS: Last year, an optional activity was for students to write a short letter to a future band student. This year I adjust the optional activity to have the students list their top 3 tips for being successful in class, which I will then use to create a Top Ten list to give to incoming band students. I encouraged them to phrase them using kid-friendly words, being funny or serious or whatever works for them. I have only glanced at a few, but there as some goodies: "Don't eat and then play; your instrument will smell gross."

MY LIFE IN SONG: This optional activity asked students to list songs and events that are forever tied in their memories. For example, whenever they hear a particular song, a specific event is brought to mind. The students found this one to be the most challenging; some could only think of one or two and others did not even bother with this activity since it was optional and they were stuck on ideas.

PERFORM SCALE FOR BAND REWARDS POINTS: The final optional activity was the opportunity to earn more points for the Band Rewards program. There were many students who were 1-2 activities away from earning the next level, so this option gave them class time to memorize and perform scales to earn points.

Overall, this packet was successful. The students could complete the activities in any order, and jump around to difference activities if they felt "stuck" on something. They were also able to work together and assist each other. The atmosphere in the room was "controlled chaos." I see my students for 80 minutes every other day, so most were completed the requirements and the optional activities of their choice within 3 classes (240 minutes). Of course I had a few stragglers that struggled with time-management, but perhaps that was a lesson they needed to learn :)